top of page
Search

Why an Immigration Judge's Removal Order Issued When You Were Not in Court Does Not Always Have to Be the End of Your Case

2 days ago
4 min read

If an immigration judge ordered you removed because you missed a hearing, that order is not always the end of your case. In many situations you can ask the court to cancel it, but only by filing a motion to reopen on one of three specific legal grounds, and often only within a strict deadline that starts running the day the order is entered.


What an in absentia removal order is


Under INA 240(b)(5)(A), an immigration judge can order a person removed without holding a hearing if the person does not show up and the Department of Homeland Security proves, by clear, unequivocal, and convincing evidence, that written notice of the hearing was properly provided and is removable as charged. There is no direct appeal of an in absentia order to the Board of Immigration Appeals. The only way to challenge one is to ask the immigration judge who entered it to reopen the case.


Why missing a hearing does not automatically end the case


An in absentia removal order can be rescinded if the person who was ordered removed files a motion to reopen showing one of three things, under INA 240(b)(5)(C) and the corresponding regulation at 8 C.F.R. 1003.23(b)(4)(ii): that the failure to appear was because of exceptional circumstances, that the person never received proper written notice of the hearing, or that the person was in federal or state custody at the time and the failure to appear was through no fault of their own. Proving any one of the three is enough. The immigration judge does not get to rescind the order on sympathy alone, the motion has to fit one of these three categories and come with evidence to support it.


What counts as exceptional circumstances


The statute, at INA 240(e)(1), defines exceptional circumstances as circumstances beyond the person's control. The law gives specific examples: battery or extreme cruelty against the person or against a child or parent of the person, serious illness of the person, or the serious illness or death of the person's spouse, child, or parent. The statute is clear that less compelling circumstances do not qualify, so a missed bus, a scheduling mix up, or ordinary work obligations generally will not be enough on their own. The circumstances that do qualify tend to involve something serious and genuinely outside the person's control that happened at the time of the hearing.


Deadlines and limits that apply


The deadline depends on which ground the motion relies on. A motion based on exceptional circumstances must be filed within 180 days after the in absentia order was entered. A motion based on lack of proper notice, or on the person having been in custody through no fault of their own, can be filed at any time, with no outside deadline. Either way, a person may file only one motion to reopen to rescind a given in absentia order, so the motion needs to be built correctly and supported with evidence the first time. Filing the motion also triggers an automatic stay of removal while the immigration judge decides it, so the government cannot legally remove the person while a properly filed motion is pending.


What to do if you were ordered removed in absentia


Because the 180 day deadline for the exceptional circumstances ground is the shortest of the available paths, and because only one motion can be filed, time and preparation both matter. Anyone who learns they were ordered removed after missing a hearing should gather whatever evidence explains what happened, medical records, proof of a mailing address problem, police or hospital records, court or custody records, as soon as possible, and should talk with an immigration attorney promptly rather than waiting. Because the notice based and custody based grounds have no outside deadline, someone who believes they never actually received notice of their hearing should not assume it is too late to ask the court to look at it, even if significant time has passed.


Frequently asked questions


Can I appeal an in absentia removal order to the Board of Immigration Appeals?

No. The Board does not have jurisdiction over a direct appeal of an in absentia order. The only way to challenge it is a motion to reopen filed with the immigration judge who entered it.


How long do I have to file a motion to reopen an in absentia order?

It depends on the ground. A motion based on exceptional circumstances must be filed within 180 days of the order. A motion based on lack of proper notice, or on the person having been in custody through no fault of their own, has no outside filing deadline.


What happens to my case while the motion to reopen is pending?

Removal is automatically stayed while the immigration judge decides a properly filed motion to reopen an in absentia order, so the government cannot carry out the removal order during that time.


Can I file more than one motion to reopen an in absentia removal order?

No. The regulations allow only one such motion per in absentia order, which is why it needs to be filed correctly and fully supported the first time.


What if I never received notice of my hearing date?

If you can show you never received proper written notice of the hearing, you can file a motion to reopen on that ground at any time, without the 180 day deadline that applies to the exceptional circumstances ground.


This article is general information about how in absentia removal orders work, not legal advice about any individual case. If you or a family member was ordered removed after missing an immigration court hearing, the attorneys at Katsivalis & Anderson Law are available to help. Call the Chicago office at 773.657.3633, the Milwaukee office at 414.502.8434, the Austin office at 512.535.1837, or our toll free line at 866.657.8472, or visit kaimmigrationlaw.com.

 
 
  • TikTok
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
bottom of page